|

How Does it Work?
What are the Limits?
How Do You Set-Up the Benefits?
How Does the Business Directly Benefit?
How Does the ETC Acquire and Provide Passes to Employees?
What if the Employee is Responsible for Acquiring
Passes?
How is Parking Cash Out Affected?
What are the Requirements for Pre-tax Payroll
Systems?
Does an Employer Have Much Flexibility with
Commuter Benefits?
Issues Regarding Other Commute Solutions Strategies
Resources
Forms / Templates
Disclaimer: The following information
on commuter tax benefits is provided for general information only
and is not tax advice or legal opinion. Please consult with the
Internal Revenue Service or your tax attorney for more information.
Note: Please consult
the IRS for the latest updated tax benefits information. It is
possible that legislation regarding tax benefits may have changed
since this manual was developed.
Employers can increase their subsidies to
Commute Solutions participants or save on the cost of providing
these incentives by using commuter tax benefitsspecial tax
code regulations that significantly reduce the cost of some commuter
programs.
The Internal Revenue Service Code 132 (F)
allows spending up to $100 for commuter vehicles and $180 for parking,
tax-free. In other words, neither the employer nor the employee
pays any taxes on these costs up to these limits.
Savings can be significant. For instance,
Capital Metro vanpools operating out of the service area pay a per-mile
fee, which can often get expensive for commutes from remote areas.
If employees had to pay the entire cost of a $120-per-month vanpool
fee, they might think the cost was prohibitive. But by not paying
taxes on the first $100 of that fee, they save about $30, depending
on their tax bracket. Suddenly, the $120 fee has plummeted to $90,
making it seem much more reasonable.
Because the strategy incurs very little cost
to an employer and has the potential for cost savings all around,
an ETC should always consider implementing a commuter tax benefit
program.
How Does it Work?
The IRS only offers the tax benefitscalled "qualified
transportation fringe benefits"for parking, transit and
"commuter highway vehicles." The IRS defines commuter
highway vehicles as those with space for at least six passengers
(excluding the driver) that use 80 percent of their mileage on commute-related
trips. Essentially they're talking about a vanpool!
Unfortunately, other Commute Solutions strategies
such as carpools, bicycling and walking do not receive these tax
benefits. Tax benefits also are not allowed for:
- Independent contractors
- Business owners who are in partnerships
- Those with two percent or more shares
in a S Corporation
- Sole proprietors
What are the Limits?
The tax-free limits are:
- $100 per month per employee for transit
and vanpool fees
- $180 per month per employee for qualified
parking expenses (at or near the employee work site)
How Do You
Setup the Benefits?
Commuter benefits are provided in one of three ways:
1) The employer covers the entire cost of
the benefit. The employees do not have to pay taxes on what they
receive up to the set limits. The employer also does not have to
expend money for payroll taxes on the amounts up to the set limits.
2) The employer sets up a pretax system on
money reserved from the employee's payroll to cover the cost of
the benefit.
3) The employer and employee share the cost.
Examples:
1) A company offers all of its employees a free transit pass (valued
at $10-17) and vanpool fees covered up to $100. The company pays
no payroll taxes on the benefits, and the employees are not taxed
either. The company can also pay up to $180 in parking expenses
per month for an employee without incurring any payroll taxes.
2) A company's employees are required to
pay for transit and vanpool fees, but the company has set up a pretax
system. The amount of the monthly passes are taken out of each employees
check before being taxed.
For transit riders, the $10-$17 for a monthly
pass is well below the $100 limit allowed by law, as are most of
the vanpooler passes at $25 a month. However, vanpool commutes from
well outside the Capital Metro service area could cost each rider
$120 per month. The company's payroll system does not tax the employee
up to the $100 limit, but applies regular withholding of taxes to
the remaining $20. The employee can also include up to $180 per
month in parking in the pretax payroll system.
3) A company shares its commuter benefit
costs with the employees so that each pays half. The company doesn't
incur any payroll taxes for the portion it provides, nor does the
employee pay any taxes on the amount received, up to the monthly
limits.
So bus riders get $5 for a monthly pass and
cover the other $5 themselves. An out-of-service area Capital Metro
vanpool that costs $120 per month to the employee would still only
be eligible for savings to the $100 limit per month. The employer
might pay $60 toward the pass, but only $40 of the remaining $60
would be eligible for the pretax system from the employee's payroll.
Once again, the company and employee can
split the cost of parking, but each only receives tax benefits up
to the total limit of $180 per month.
How Does the Business
Directly Benefit?
By providing a commuter benefit instead of additional salary, the
business saves money. Although both commuter benefits and salary
are tax deductible as a business expense, the commuter benefit does
not require payroll taxes, thus saving the business a substantial
amount of money.
How Does the ETC
Acquire and Provide Passes to Employees?
Most transit authorities and vanpool providers have staff experienced
in helping set-up easy ways for an employer to purchase and distribute
passes. Capital Metro is one example and operates an Employer Transit
Pass Sales Program that offers free delivery and discounts on bulk
orders. Vanpool pass fees also can be billed.
Here's how the system might work for each
of the commuter benefit options with the employer handling the purchase
and distribution:
1) Employer covers entire cost of commuter
benefit:
A company pays for its employees' transit and vanpool passes up
to the limit of $100 a month. The company simply places an advance
order each month for its 25 bus passes, which are delivered at a
discount, and distributes them to the employees. Vanpool fees are
paid each month directly to the provider. In the case where the
fee might exceed the company's limit (and tax limit) of $100, the
company might simply deduct the additional amount from the employee's
pay.
2) The employer sets up a pretax system
on money reserved from the employee's payroll to cover the cost
of the benefit:
The employer can still order transit and vanpool passes, as well
as administer payment to the transit provider on behalf of the employees.
The company simply deducts the amount needed from each employee's
payroll.
3) The employer and employee share
the cost:
The employer can still order transit and vanpool passes and administer
payment for them. The company simply deducts the amount neededthe
employee's sharefrom their payroll.
What if the Employee
is Responsible for Acquiring Passes?
If employees purchase the passes, a pretax system isn't reserving
money from their payroll for company-made purchases, and as a result,
they aren't getting the commuter tax benefits!
If the employer is providing the money to
cover all or a portion of the cost of passes, a few rules apply,
because the Tax Code prohibits cash reimbursement to employees for
passes in most instances.
For instance, an employer can't simply give
its employees money, tell them to go buy passes and then ask for
receipts. Nor can it have the employee bring them a receipt and
give them the compensation (in most cases).
Instead, employers have to provide the employees
with vouchers purchased from a for-profit company or nonprofit group.
The vouchers then can be used to pay for transit and vanpool passes
from thousands of different providers around the country. Of course,
most voucher companies charge employers a fee, which can add up
quickly with a large number of passes.
ETCs take note, because in most cases it's
easy for employers to acquire passes, the following information
probably won't apply to the Central Texas region.
Vouchers are popular in areas where several
different transit agencies and/or vanpool providers operate and
it would be too unruly for an employer to handle purchases and distribution
from so many entities. Or, in some instances, getting various passes
out to different employees by mail could be costly.
Under the Tax Code, employers only can use
cash reimbursement in a couple of situations:
1) The employer can demonstrate that
voucher systems are not "readily available." What
"readily available" means has been a subject of ongoing
debate. Voucher companies are providing their services in nearly
every metropolitan area in the country, so it would seem they are
"readily available" in these regions. However, the legal
definition is much more involved and considers whether providing
vouchers would incur "significant administrative costs"
to the employer. And the definitions continue from here on! (See
Resources, below, for more sources of information.)
2) Starting January 1, 2004, an employer
can take advantage of the "safe harbor" rule that
specifically defines "significant administrative costs"
as voucher fees that are in excess of one percent of the average
monthly value of the vouchers. It is anticipated that this ruling
will free up many employers to offer reimbursements in the future.
The point for ETCs in Central Texas is that
it's preferable to have the employer handle the purchase and distribution
of passes. If, for some reason, reimbursement is necessary, be sure
to have a tax attorney review the code and the resources below to
determine the proper course.
How is Parking Cash
Out Affected?
When an employer uses parking cash out (See
Section 2, Chapter 6), the amount given to the employee is treated
as taxable salary, unless the employee then uses the compensation
for transit or vanpool passes. In that case, the same limits apply,
and up to $100 can be tax free.
Employers benefit the most when employees
use all or a portion of the cash out to pay for transit or vanpool
passes. This precludes them from having to pay additional payroll
taxes on the cash out as additional salary to the employee.
What are the
Requirements for Pretax Payroll Systems?
ETCs are in luck. The requirements are minimal and flexible. The
employee simply must provide the employer with a written election
(stating that the employee elects to take advantage of the benefit)
with the following information:
- Date of the election
- The amount of compensation to be reduced
- The period the benefits will be provided
A sample form is included below.
Does an Employer
Have Much Flexibility with Commuter Benefits?
Employers have incredible flexibility in implementing the benefits
as they choose. Consult with your human resources or payroll department
if you don't understand the terminology below.
No written plan is required for the benefit
- The benefit is not subject to anti-discriminatory
requirements. An employer can offer the benefit to one department
and not another, or even one employee and not another. The value
of the benefit can vary by employee as well.
- Unused compensation reductions (payroll
reserved) may carry-over to another time period. For instance,
if employees don't use their reserved payroll for a transit pass
one month, they don't lose the tax savings, as long as they don't
exceed the average monthly limit of $100 per month.
- There are no irrevocable elections (employees
can change or nullify the election as needed)
Issues Regarding
Other Commute Solutions Strategies
ETCs should meet with the employer's tax attorney to discuss subsidies
for strategies not covered by the IRS code (e.g., carpooling, bicycling
and walking). Any subsidy seen by the IRS as having a financial
value may be determined to be the same as additional salary. In
that case, the employer could write-off the subsidy as a business
expense, but also would be responsible for paying additional payroll
taxes.
The employee also would need to pay taxes
on the subsidy, as if it were regular income. The only exceptions
are called "de minimis fringe benefits," amounts so small
they are not taxed. A rule of thumb is that the amount would be
$25 or less in one year. Parking costs given to participants are
not taxable up to the $180 limit.
Resources
Commuter Choice
www.commuterchoice.gov
The Environmental Protection Agency Web site for the Commuter Choice
Leadership Initiative contains a thorough briefing paper on commuter
tax benefits.
The Association for Commuter Transportation
www.actweb.org
202-393-3497
ACT provides ongoing education and monitoring of commuter tax benefit
issues.
Internal Revenue Service
www.irs.gov
IRS
Ruling on 132(f) (Regarding Vouchers and Other Issues)
Forms / Templates
Example
of How Commuter Tax Benefits Compare to Additional Salary (Word)
Example of How Commuter
Tax Benefits Compare to Additional Salary (PDF)
|